There's something about a really good Italian sub.

Maybe it's the fresh bread. Maybe it's the combination of Italian meats, cheese, onions, peppers, and just the right amount of oil.

Or maybe it's finding that little neighborhood deli that makes a sandwich so good you're already thinking about your next visit before you've finished the first one.

Credit: Garret Doll
Credit: Garret Doll

I may be partial to Doug's Hoagies.  The sandwiches are amazing, they are great people and it's close to the apartment. LOL.

“Doug’s Hoagies is one of my regular stops in Dover, and for good reason. Everything is made to order, always fresh, and they make a seriously good hoagie. And while we're talking about Doug's, don't sleep on the tots. I'm a big fan of those, too!”

I've been on a bit of a mission to find some of New Hampshire's best food, and this time I wanted to settle a pretty important question.

Who makes the best Italian sub in New Hampshire?

So I asked New Hampshire residents, and they had plenty of suggestions.

Some of the answers were exactly what you'd expect. Others were places I hadn't heard of, which is exactly why I love asking these questions.

And one of the biggest surprises? Just how much love a certain grocery store received.

The Italian Sub Favorites New Hampshire Keeps Mentioning

Moe's Italian Sandwiches was one of the most frequently mentioned names, with plenty of longtime customers showing their loyalty.

John Plaisted wrote, "Of course my go to has always been Moes for 67 years."

Several people specifically recommended the original downtown Portsmouth location.

But right alongside Moe's was Market Basket.

Yes, Market Basket.

READ MORE: A Strange Stone Found in New Hampshire Has Puzzled Experts for 154 Years

People weren't just recommending the grocery store because it's convenient. A lot of them were talking about the portion sizes and the price.

Kathy Brickley wrote, "I've had a Market Basket Italian sub and it was delicious and very reasonably priced!"

And Perry Laughner added, "Don't knock it if you haven't tried it."

The Smaller Shops Getting Some Serious Love

Beyond those two familiar names, several independently owned shops received multiple recommendations.

Jeannotte's Market in Nashua had an especially enthusiastic following, as did S&S Italian Market in Plaistow.

Natasha's Sweets & Eats in Rochester received plenty of support, too.

Darlene Bruedle said, "Ya gotta try one from Natasha's Sweets & Eats because once you do you won't want one from anywhere else!"

And Sub Crazy in Meredith earned multiple mentions for its Italian sandwiches.

Austinsfooodadventures kept the recommendation short and sweet: "Sub Crazy in Meredith! Old school Italian!"

Over in Greenville, several listeners nominated Country Mile, while others pointed to Joe's Meat Shoppe in North Hampton, Rig A Tony's in Derry, and Bill Cahill's Super Subs in Hudson.

To round out the list was Benny's Fresh Eats & Market in Laconia

Credit: Getty Images
Credit: Getty Images

What Actually Makes a Great Italian Sub?

Here's where I think this conversation gets interesting.

I've put together a gallery of the places listeners recommended most often, along with their locations, so you can find one near you.

13 New Hampshire Spots Locals Love for Italian Subs

We asked New Hampshire locals where to find the best Italian subs, and they delivered! From longtime sandwich shops and hidden neighborhood delis to a few surprising favorites, here are 13 spots Granite Staters say are worth checking out. Did your favorite make the list?

Gallery Credit: Garret Doll

Everybody seems to have their own definition of the perfect Italian.

Some people want their sandwich toasted. Others prefer it cold. Some swear by a traditional combination of Italian deli meats, while others care just as much about the bread, pickles, peppers, or dressing.

And that's what I like about these food conversations. One person's longtime favorite might be a completely new discovery for somebody else.

Now I'm curious: What's your Italian sub order? Everything on it, extra hots, toasted, or do you keep it simple?

And more importantly, which New Hampshire sandwich shop should I try first?

15 Places That Perfectly Capture the Heart of New Hampshire

Some places make you stop and say, "This is New Hampshire." Whether it's a breathtaking mountain summit, a peaceful lakeside sunrise, a charming coastal town, or a hidden gem tucked away in the woods, these destinations capture the beauty, character, and spirit of the Granite State. Here are 15 places that belong in every New Hampshire photo gallery.

Gallery Credit: Garret Doll

More From 97.5 WOKQ