We continue with Garret's Creepy Fact Storytime... Back to Portsmouth we go.

If you've ever spent any time along the Portsmouth waterfront, there's a good chance you've looked across the river and noticed that enormous castle-looking building sitting over at the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard.

You know the one I'm talking about.

Credit: Getty Images
Credit: Getty Images

Huge walls. Tall towers. Arched windows. It looks like something you'd expect to see in an old horror movie.

And I've always wondered about that place.

Turns out, it wasn't built for royalty. It wasn't some wealthy family's waterfront mansion.

It was a prison. And its history is a lot more interesting than I ever imagined.

New England Had Its Own Alcatraz

The building is the former Portsmouth Naval Prison, located on Seavey's Island in Kittery, Maine.

Yes, Maine. Even though it's called the Portsmouth Naval Prison, it's actually across the Piscataqua River from Portsmouth, New Hampshire.

The prison opened in 1908 and eventually earned the nickname "Alcatraz of the East."

When it was constructed, the building was considered the largest poured-concrete structure in the world.

And you can understand why it earned that intimidating nickname.

Between the island location, the powerful currents of the Piscataqua River, and those castle-like towers, it wasn't exactly the kind of place you'd want to find yourself checking into.

The Island Was Holding Prisoners Before the Castle Even Existed

Here's something that surprised me.

According to the Naval Sea Systems Command, the site was originally home to Camp Long, a prisoner-of-war camp established during the Spanish-American War in 1898.

More than 1,600 Spanish prisoners of war were held there.

About a decade later, the naval prison opened on the same site.

READ MORE: The Strange History Behind Portsmouth's Oldest Cemetery

And over the next 66 years, an extraordinary number of men would pass through those walls.

According to research highlighted by the Portsmouth Public Library, more than 86,000 men passed through the prison between 1908 and 1974.

During World War II, the prison held more than 3,000 sailors and Marines at one time.

And there's another piece of World War II history connected to the building.

After Germany surrendered in 1945, German submarine crews were questioned at the prison by U.S. naval intelligence.

Think about that for a second.

A place we drive past today was once part of the military history of two world wars.

 What Happened When the Prison Closed?

In 1974, the Navy officially closed the Portsmouth Naval Prison.

And what happened next is part of what makes this place so fascinating.

The enormous building remained standing.

For more than 50 years, the old castle has watched over Portsmouth Harbor, while life has continued on both sides of the river.

There have been multiple attempts over the years to find a new use for the building, but none has resulted in a completed redevelopment.

And it isn't just the history that's difficult to ignore.

It's the appearance.

Those towering walls. The rows of windows. The old fortress architecture.

Knowing that thousands of men once lived behind those walls gives the place a completely different feeling.

You can see over 300 pictures of the prison from the Naval History and Heritage Command website.

Could the Castle Finally Get a New Life?

There's actually been a recent development involving the old prison.

In August 2026, New Hampshire Public Radio reported that Senator Jeanne Shaheen had requested $5 million in federal funding for a feasibility study examining whether the former prison could become a "sailor campus."

The idea would be to explore recreational programs and support services for sailors stationed at Portsmouth Naval Shipyard while their submarines undergo repairs.

It's an interesting possibility for a building that has sat unused as a prison for more than half a century.

But the proposal was still in the planning stage when it was reported.

Credit: Getty Images
Credit: Getty Images

The Castle Is Still There, Watching Over the Harbor

One thing worth mentioning: the old prison isn't open for regular public tours. It's located within an active naval shipyard with restricted access.

But you don't have to go inside to appreciate just how unusual this piece of Seacoast history really is.

The next time you're walking along the Portsmouth waterfront, take a look across the river.

That enormous castle isn't just another historic building.

It was once one of the most recognizable military prisons in the country.

And more than a century after it opened, it still has a way of making you wonder what life was like behind those walls.

Personally, I think it looks creepy enough from the outside. I don't need to find out what those empty hallways sound like at night.

Iconic Diners in New Hampshire

There’s just something about a diner… the coffee that never stops coming, the same booth people have probably been sitting in for 30 years, and a breakfast that somehow hits every single time.

As I’ve been getting to know New Hampshire, one thing became very clear — this state LOVES its diners. And not just any diners… we’re talking iconic, been-here-forever, locals-swear-by-it kind of places.

So I went down the rabbit hole (and got very hungry in the process) and pulled together some of the most iconic diners across the Granite State.

Did we get your favorite? Or are you already mad we missed one? 😅

Gallery Credit: Garret Doll

15 Best Waterfalls in New Hampshire (Worth the Trip Every Time)

Gallery Credit: Garret Doll

More From 97.5 WOKQ