Here Are the 10 Massachusetts Pizza Places Barstool’s Dave Portnoy Has Reviewed in the First Half of 2026

Barstool's Dave Portnoy has continued his pizza review quest in June 2026, hitting up three more Massachusetts spots to give them his ratings.

That means he's now visited 10 places in New England so far this year, all of them in the Bay State. (Sadly, he hasn't been back to Maine or New Hampshire since 2023 and 2024, respectively.)

There's still plenty of 2026 and pizza joints left for that number to increase, but let's take a look at the current list.

Dave Portnoy Reviews Massachusetts Pizza in 2026

A majority of Portnoy's 2026 Massachusetts One Bite Pizza reviews landed in January, which seems like a pretty good way to kick off the year.

One of them even included New England Patriots quarterback Drake Maye's wife, Ann Michael Maye, at Gianni's Deli and Pizza in Needham.

Thankfully, none in the first batch were duds, and the lowest still earned a 6.3.

It wouldn't be until about five months later that Portnoy would return to Massachusetts for another dose of pizza goodness with places that he would rate all above a score of 7.

Let's dive in and check out all the Massachusetts pizza places he's reviewed so far this year.

READ MORE: New England Patriots Coach Mike Vrabel Spotted at This No. 1 New Hampshire Pizza Place

Have you ever been to Fowler House Cafe in Quincy, Massachusetts, Portnoy's highest-rated Massachusetts place for 2026 at 8.1?

One of his more recent reviews at Auntie Dot's in Worcester came close, landing a great 7.9.

When Portnoy also gets to meet the owners and learn the history of some of these places, they can often stand out even more. It's that extra element that combines with the pizza itself to make it even more enticing to go check out.

Will you be going to any of these pizza places this year?